Myth Buster: EVs are just as bad for the environment as fossil fuel cars

December 22, 2020

Myth: EVs are just as bad for the envi­ron­ment as fos­sil fuel cars because the ener­gy fuel­ing them comes from oil/gas/coal and due to heavy reliance on extrac­tive indus­tries for manufacturing.

Myth BUSTED: EVs run more effi­cient­ly when com­pared to fos­sil fuel cars. Addi­tion­al­ly, EVs have zero tailpipe emis­sions, leav­ing the air clean­er as you dri­ve. EVs pro­duce few­er emis­sions over­all when com­pared to fos­sil fuel cars, espe­cial­ly as the elec­tric grid becomes more renew­able. Final­ly, EVs allow for sec­ondary bat­tery appli­ca­tions and tech­nol­o­gy is con­tin­u­al­ly improving.

One of the most common—and contentious—questions that elec­tric vehi­cle (EV) experts are fre­quent­ly asked is, “are elec­tric vehi­cles real­ly bet­ter for the envi­ron­ment? Espe­cial­ly in the case of bat­ter­ies and the man­u­fac­tur­ing process? And, what about when EVs are dri­ving off fos­sil fuel-based electricity?

This is a prick­ly ques­tion for a rea­son! Are EVs 100% green with no asso­ci­at­ed emis­sions? Of course not! Noth­ing that is man­u­fac­tured on an indus­tri­al scale today can reach zero emis­sions or “car­bon neu­tral­i­ty.” How­ev­er, it is still true that elec­tric vehi­cles are bet­ter for the environment—and your health—when com­pared to gaso­line and diesel vehicles.

Effi­cien­cy:

Let’s first start with effi­cien­cy. The aver­age EV is 2.25 times more effi­cient than a com­pa­ra­ble inter­nal com­bus­tion engine (ICE) vehi­cle. While an ICE vehi­cle is 40% effi­cient, a com­pa­ra­ble EV is about 90% effi­cient (Ruf­fo 2020). It is this effi­cien­cy, even when charg­ing the aver­age EV off a dirty (coal-based) elec­tric grid, that makes EVs more envi­ron­men­tal­ly friend­ly when com­pared to the aver­age ICE vehi­cle. Think of it this way: you may be charg­ing your car off a dirty grid, but you are get­ting more mileage out of that ener­gy input in an EV. In a fos­sil fueled car, you are sim­ply burn­ing up 60% of your ener­gy to get the car to run, while in an EV, only 10% of that ener­gy is wast­ed. Addi­tion­al­ly, EVs do not require petro­le­um extrac­tion, refin­ing of petro­le­um into gas, or trans­port­ing that gas to refu­el­ing sta­tions across the world (Crid­er, 2020).

Zero Tailpipe Emissions: 

Sec­ond­ly, EVs have low­er life-cycle emis­sions as com­pared to gas cars, even when fueled by coal-pow­ered ener­gy (Patel, 2022). One major con­trib­u­tor to this fact is that they have zero tailpipe emis­sions (also known as direct emis­sions). This is also true for plug-in hybrid EVs (PHEVs) when run­ning off the bat­tery. It should be empha­sized that PHEVs have short­er elec­tric ranges com­pared to all-bat­tery elec­tric vehi­cles (BEVs) and thus need to be charged more fre­quent­ly to keep emis­sions low. If you for­get to recharge your PHEV after run­ning down the bat­tery range, then you will be emit­ting fos­sil-fuel based tailpipe emis­sions. How­ev­er, when run­ning on the bat­tery, EVs do not emit nox­ious gas cre­at­ed from the burn­ing of fos­sil fuels in your engine. This lack of air-based pol­lu­tion allows for clean­er air, less smog, few­er pol­lu­tants intro­duced in our water­ways, and health­i­er and hap­pi­er peo­ple! (Crid­er, 2020; Wil­son 2020). Just imag­ine walk­ing down a busy street and not cough­ing on the fumes of the heavy-duty pick-up idling next you. The future is bright!

Clean­er Elec­tric­i­ty Grids = Few­er Indi­rect Emissions

Next, EVs can be fueled by renew­able ener­gy. If you have solar pan­els, pay for a renew­able ener­gy mix from your util­i­ty, or have an off-grid sys­tem, the elec­tric­i­ty will not be asso­ci­at­ed with any fuel-based emis­sions! Like­wise, as the Nation’s elec­tric grid becomes increas­ing­ly renew­able, your EV’s fos­sil fuel ener­gy impact will like­wise reduce. Cur­rent­ly, Colorado’s grid is still about 45% coal-based, how­ev­er, with Colorado’s Renew­able Ener­gy Stan­dard, renew­ables are pro­lif­er­at­ing in the state, and coal pow­er plants are con­tin­u­ing to shut down (Ener­gy Infor­ma­tion Admin­is­tra­tion, 2020).

Sec­ondary Mar­ket Appli­ca­tions & Tech­no­log­i­cal Advancements: 

What about the envi­ron­men­tal impacts of bat­tery man­u­fac­ture and raw mate­r­i­al extrac­tion used to build the cars them­selves? The pol­lu­tion cre­at­ed through extrac­tive process­es and pro­duc­tion for EVs are on par with or slight­ly high­er than the man­u­fac­tur­ing process of build­ing an ICE vehi­cle (Ellsmoor, 2019). How­ev­er, EV bat­ter­ies are often reused in sec­ondary appli­ca­tions, like serv­ing as gen­er­a­tor back­up bat­ter­ies. These sec­ondary appli­ca­tions also reduce the need for more extrac­tive min­ing, as pre­cious resources can be reused in oth­er mar­kets (Ellsmoor, 2019).

Final­ly, remem­ber that elec­tric vehi­cles are still in the begin­ning stages of devel­op­ment. The design, man­u­fac­tur­ing, and per­for­mance of EVs and their bat­ter­ies con­tin­ue to devel­op and improve every year (Reich­muth, 2020). As more EVs hit the road, there will be greater oppor­tu­ni­ty to study and improve how they per­form in real-world appli­ca­tions. EVs will con­tin­ue to improve in ener­gy effi­cien­cy and performance—driving towards a green­er hori­zon and leav­ing fos­sil-fueled cars in the rearview mirror.

Source 1: John­na Crid­er "U.S Depart­ment of Ener­gy: EVs Emit Few­er Emis­sions, Bet­ter for the Envi­ron­ment." 19 Octo­ber 2020. <https://cleantechnica.com/2020/10/19/u‑s-department-of-energy-evs-emit-fewer-emissions-better-for-the-environment/>.

Source 2: James Ellsmoor. 20 May 2019. "Are Elec­tric Vehi­cles Real­ly Bet­ter for the Envi­ron­ment?" Forbes. <https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesellsmoor/2019/05/20/are-electric-vehicles-really-better-for-the-environment/?sh=1767576a76d2>.

Source 3: Ener­gy Infor­ma­tion Admin­is­tra­tion, State Ener­gy Data Sys­tem. 19 March 2020 "Col­orado Pro­file Overview". <https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=CO>.

Source 4: David Reich­muth. 11 Feb­ru­ary 2020. "Are Elec­tric Vehi­cles Real­ly Bet­ter for the Cli­mate? Yes. Here's Why" Union of Con­cerned Sci­en­tists. <https://blog.ucsusa.org/dave-reichmuth/are-electric-vehicles-really-better-for-the-climate-yes-heres-why>.

Source 5: Gus­ta­vo Hen­rique Ruf­fo "ICE Vs. EV — Do You Know How Inef­fi­cient Com­bus­tion Engines Are?" 10 Jan­u­ary 2020. <https://insideevs.com/features/392202/ice-vs-ev-inefficient-combustion-engine/>.

Source 6: Kea Wil­son. 28 Octo­ber 2020. "Study: How Cars Are Mak­ing Us All Depressed (Even If We Don't Dri­ve)" Streets­Blo­gUSA <https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/28/study-how-cars-are-making-us-all-depressed-even-if-we-dont-drive/>.

Source 7: Prachi Patel. 13 Jan­u­ary 2022. "In a com­par­i­son of life-cycle emis­sions, EVs crushed com­bus­tion cars" Anthro­pocene Mag­a­zine <https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2022/01/evs-crush-combustion-cars-even-when-weighing-emissions-from-battery-and-electricity-production/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=evs-crush-combustion-cars-even-when-weighing-emissions-from-battery-and-electricity-production>

Recent Posts

Electric Bike Grant Opportunities

The State of Colorado is offering two e-bike grants: one for local and Tribal governments to offer e-bike rebates, and one for local government, nonprofits, and tribal governments to fund e-bike deployment projects. Learn more here: Local Government Community E-Bike...

Quarterly EVs on the Road in Colorado

Quarterly EVs on the Road in Colorado

Drive Electric Colorado presents a Quarterly EVs in Colorado report. Using data from the Colorado Energy Office’s EV Dashboard and the Alternative Fueling Station Locator from the Department of Energy, below is the most current and accurate sales data for EVs and...

[/et_pb_column]

Take the pledge to make your next car electric!